Two weeks ago, a two thousand strong crowd gathered at India Gate to demand the release of senior journalist Syed Mohammed Kazmi, who was arrested by the Delhi Police Special Cell in connection with last month’s blast outside the Israeli embassy in Delhi. “If he is a terrorist, why would so many people come out and protest and demand his release,” asked a protester.
Even as leading English dailies give the impression that ‘Few vouch for Kazmi’s innocence’, the truth remains that the arrest is shrouded in mystery. Is there not more than just a coincidence that critics of Israel are now being hounded by Indian authorities because they dare to question Israel’s absurd claims about the occupation? Has Israel grown so influential within the internal security machinery that they can order the arrest of someone whose only fault might be to ask the right questions?
There is need to begin to demystify the myth that our media is truly free of interests and pressures. The Kazmi arrest may provide some clues as to who controls and manoeuvres our media.
Is Media “Safe” In India?
By Adil Akhzer
01 April, 2012
The recent arrest (February 14) of one of the eminent Indian journalists Syed Kazmi and also a midnight police raid (March 11) of Frontline magazine Delhi Bureau chief, John Cherian, which police later framed as a “case of misunderstanding” has forced many within the journalist fraternity to ponder as to whether they are safe in a democratic country like India?
No one can deny the fact that media in India is working under a free sky, and unlike China and other countries where there are restrictions on what media can report, Indian media has never come under any kind of pressure. However, the latest incident where Kazmi, an accredited journalist, a father of three, and formerly a public television broadcaster, who was arrested for his alleged role in the “Sticky bomb” case on the Israeli diplomatic car and for which the Delhi Police has failed to provide any authentic proof of his involvement- is clearly an indication that media is not free anymore and now any time, any journalist can be picked up and framed with any charge by the police, depending upon the situation.
The arrest of Kazmi, which is still shrouded in mystery, has not helped the investigating agencies to crack the car blast case. It is interesting to look the circumstances under which Kazmi was arrested, which in itself looks like a scene out of a Bollywood potboiler. According to reports, Kazmi was picked up from the India Islamic Cultural Centre in New Delhi at about 11.30 am on February 14, subsequently he was taken to the office of the Special Cell of the Delhi police. However, officially his arrest has been shown in the records as 8.30 pm. Later in the night, officers of the Special Cell raided Kazmi’s house and seized his laptop, Press Information Bureau card, passport, driving license and some other documents. The police also seized his Alto car that and the two-wheeler that they claim was used for the reccee of the Israeli target. Citing this arbitrariness, Kazmi’s son revealed an even more important thing. He said, “I was forced to sign on the arrest memo at 2.30 am. We asked them to wait till morning, but they threatened us”. So is it not right to say that Kazmi has been a victim at the hands of Delhi Police. If the police can arrest, an established and prominent journalist in the capital, can’t they arrest an ordinary scribe at any time, if they want and put fictitious charges on him?
It has already been reported that after Kazmi’s arrest, so far Delhi police has not been able to produce any kind of substantial evidence linking him to the aiding and abetting of the “sticky bomb” conspiracy. More interestingly, it is curious to know that the police are tight lipped on the matter on the real culprits behind the attack. One can guess the things by this simple situation: if you are a journalist and you would call Delhi Police PRO who is in charge of the media, he will not be able to say or utter anything related to this case.
It is indeed a matter of alarm that the repeated protests by the various media organisations at national and international level against Kazmi’s arrest have not yielded any result. “Investigations can continue but he should be released on bail since he is cooperating with the investigations. We do not want the police to indulge in a media trial. If there is any need for information to be given, it should only be through an official press note,” a statement issued by the largest journalist body in the country, the Delhi Union of Journalists. The union’s statement also hinted at foul play in Kazmi’s arrest when it said, “Possibly Kazmi’s close association with the Iranian media outlets is being used by the police to implicate him”. Though the statement was issued keeping Kazmi in mind, the bigger concern on the journalist fraternity’s mind is that Kazmi’s arrest can have repercussions on other scribes too. A journalist would definitely now think twice whether he/she should work for any international outlet or not, because the message from the Indian authorities is clear- that you can be used by the government like a puppet and no one would really care about you.
It is not easy to forget the case of Ifthikar Geelani back in 2001 when he was arrested under the Official Secrets Act, and though he was set free, it indicated one thing clearly and categorically- if the government wants, it can arrest anybody at any time and can slap you with any fictitious charge within days and you will be thrown behind the bars.
India is a democratic country where media is treated as the fourth pillar of democracy and it has already exposed involvement of many senior bureaucrats and ministers in various scams and corruption cases, forcing the government to act against the tainted minters, but it is not wrong to say that now the situation and times have changed. Now if you are a journalist, no matter for which agency you are working local, national or international, there is a possibility that a “case” can be framed against you and then he/she can be attacked, tortured, harassed and finally be set free.
Pertinently, Kazmi’s arrest is also giving sleeping nights to another category of researchers and journalists- the ones who had recently visited Syria to cover the referendum on a new constitution. They feel that now the government is constantly monitoring their activities. They are wondering as to whether the Indian government is acting under any kind of international pressure? If the answer is yes, then the time has come for the government to act against those forces, because if they don’t act now, it would ultimately create a dissent in our democracy.
Writer Is a Journalist Based In New Delhi Email: email@example.com